Over the last few years, I have had an extended back-and-forth conversation with a Roman Catholic on Twitter. Our conversation spanned a number of long threads, focusing on the liturgical evidence of eucharist found in some of the earliest major sources: the Didache (c.90), Ignatius (d.c.108), Justin Martyr (d.c.165), Irenaeus (d.c.202), and Cyprian (d.c.258).
This is Part 3. The topic is the meaning and identification of the eucharist. See the index here.

Your argument throughout this segment is very outlandish. It’s predicated upon the notion that when ancient authors refer to a eucharist or the Eucharist , they can only mean one thing, and this one things is what they mean every time they reference any kind of Eucharist.
As demonstrated with St. Irenaeus though, this is simply not the case. Ancient authors can refer to general Eucharist/Thanksgivings of all kinds of offerings, while also denoting the particular Eucharist that is holy communion. These two usages are not mutually exclusive with one another.
I’ll concede I was a bit imprecise in the original thread. I concur there are certainly times that ancient authors, including the ones I listed, use Eucharist in different senses to holy communion. My claim was that, in the relevant passages I cited, they were using Eucharist to refer to holy communion .Imprecise? That is an understatement. It remains incredibly imprecise! Let’s look at this claim again, even more carefully than before.
Did anyone actually do this in the first three centuries of the church? There is no conclusive proof that they did. None at all. I wouldn’t even consider there to be any direct evidence that they did. Not a single writing prior to the late 4th century identifies communion as “the Eucharist.” Not Irenaeus, nor Ignatius, nor Justin Martyr, nor anyone else did so.
At best, being as flexible as I can be, you can inductively ‘reason’—from what you already believe!—that what they said is logically compatible with your view. But, that’s neither evidence nor proof. It’s just formalized question begging. It is simply the acknowledgement that it might be logically possible that your view could be true. At best it isn’t an outright contradiction. That’s nowhere close to convincing!
So we need to be very precise in our claim:
This, rather simply, does not establish the fact of even a single Catholic claim. It’s a claim that is 100% compatible with the view that I have espoused, providing no unique evidence at all to the Catholic position. This is easily demonstrated:
Does the beer and cheese of the eucharist cease to be the eucharist during the agape meal?
Does the bread and wine of the eucharist cease to be the eucharist when it is consecrated for communion?
Does the oil of the eucharist cease to be the eucharist when it is applied to the forehead?
The answer to all these questions is a resounding “No!”
Not a single early writer called, titled, or designated the Lord’s Supper or Communion “the Eucharist.” The absolute farthest that you can possibly press their words—before falling afoul of question begging—is that they sometimes called consecrated bread and wine “the eucharist.” But, and this is key, calling consecrated bread and wine “the eucharist” does not mean they didn’t consider the unconsecrated bread and wine to be that same “eucharist.” In other words, it was the eucharist prior to consecration—and the Lord’s Supper!—and it remained the eucharist after consecration.
The fact that the early writers occasionally referred to the consecrated bread and wine as the eucharist is not surprising at all, as they did the same thing to the food distributed to those in need and to the oil used in anointing.
As we continue this series, we will, of necessity, discuss some of those instances, so I won’t repeat them here. But look out for them, so you’ll recognize them when you see them. I will try to refer back here whenever it comes up.
Ancient authors can refer to general Eucharist/Thanksgivings of all kinds of offerings, while also denoting the particular Eucharist that is holy communion.
While I acknowledge this principle in general, this has not been specifically established. It’s fine to understand that the word ‘thanksgiving’ can be used linguistically, syntactically, and grammatically in various different ways and in various contexts. This is undeniable. But there is a limit to how far you can apply this to specific uses of the term.
The fact that thanksgiving has different uses does not imply that the thanksgiving refers to “the particular Eucharist that is holy communion.” You simply cannot go from the general to the specific without an affirmative case they they are, indeed, different.
For example, just because thanksgiving can refer to ‘gratitude’ (e.g. in a letter where an author expresses his appreciation for another Christian), this doesn’t mean that the eucharist of the bread and wine in the sacrifice of the tithe is separate from the eucharist of the bread and wine in the consecration of communion. This is precisely what you seem to be doing, assuming that they must refer to different things. But, you cannot infer something specific from a general principle.
On the other hand, it is possible to infer the general from the specific. What I mean is this: if you see an author talking about the eucharist of the bread and wine of the communion, it is possible that this eucharist (of the communion) is part of a more generalized eucharist (of the tithe) in a part-whole relationship. And indeed it is!
In other words, you can look at evidence to try to infer from the presence of two mentioned eucharists—of the sacrificial tithe and of the consecration of communion—that they are in a general relationship (e.g. part-whole, different facets of the same thing, etc.), but you can’t infer from the presence of two mentioned eucharists that they are unrelated. The former is an argument based on affirmative evidence, while the latter is a fallacious Argument from Silence.
The Catholic position here goes beyond what is logically and rationally permissible, penetrating deep into speculative territory. You simply don’t know that it is a particular eucharist.
In fact, the Catholic here has the burden of proof to show that the bread and wine—the eucharist—of communion is not the same eucharist of the sacrificial tithe. This is going to be incredibly difficult, because the church got the bread and wine that it used during communion directly from the sacrifice of the tithe. People brought the food in, sacrificed it as part of their offerings, and then a portion was taken for the communion service. It is simply the historical reality that the eucharist of bread and wine used in communion was a portion of the bread and wine taken from thanksgiving offering.
I’m not sure what historical basis the Catholic has to claim that these are two separate eucharists. I don’t believe there is one.
Let me appeal to you by analogy.
Let’s say I own five cars, but I love one more than all the others. Now, let’s say I add a gaudy hood ornament to my favorite car. Does the car cease to be my car? Is it now a particular car that is separate from the other four cars? The answer is, all five remain my cars, but one of them has been decorated. The same is true of the eucharist. The bread, wine, cheese, grapes, beer, etc. are all the eucharist. But, if instead of decoration I consecrate some bread and wine, it does not cease to be the eucharist. It is simply consecrated eucharist.
The most we can say is that the decorated car is a particular car and the consecrated eucharist is a particular eucharist, but both retain their previous relationship with the others. They’ve simply added another attribute, like how, say, a different paint color doesn’t fundamentally alter what a car is.
The “particular eucharists” are not particular in the exclusive, separate, distinct, independent sense that the Catholic means. We will see this as we examine this topic further.